Source:
http://www.gamespy.com/goty2003/ps2/index.shtml

GameSpy - GAME OF THE YEAR PS2
順 Title 　
1 Tony Hawk's Underground Best Action Sports Game
Overall Game of the Year Nominee
2 SSX 3
3 Virtual Fighter4 Evolution Best Fighting Game
4 SOCOM2: U.S. Navy SEALs Best Online Game
Multiplayer GotY Nominee
5 Guilty Gear XX
6 Need for Speed Underground Best Racing Game
7 NCAA Football 2004 Best Sports Game
8 Culdcept 　
9 魔界戦記Disgaea Best Strategy Game
10 Xenosaga I 力意志 Best RPG

Special Award :
Award Title
Scariest Game - Silent Hill 3
Most Innovative - EyeToy
Breakout Game - Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter
Best Movie Game - The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King